Esperanto’s grammar was never the problem
Languages & Countries publikigis antaŭ 8 horoj en Esperanto Ĉu ne?
Neniu ĝenro specifite.
Proponu ĝenrojn
Ni ne povas montri ĉi tiun filmeton al vi, ĉar viaj agordoj pri kuketoj ne permesas tion al ni.
Por rigardi kaj re-agordi viajn kuketojn, vizitu la paĝon Kuketoj.
Vi povas daŭre spekti la filmeton ĉe la originala platformo:
Originala paĝo
Spekti filmon ĉe Tubaro ne ŝtelas la spekton de Jutubo. La spekto enkalkuliĝas en ambaŭ Tubaro kaj Jutubo. Mi komprenas.
- 1 Spekto
- Komentu!
- 0
Via ŝato/malŝato, ankaŭ viaj ĝenro-proponoj por ĉi tiu afiŝo estas konservita nur en Tubaro, ili ne estas sendataj ekster niaj serviloj. Simile, la statistikoj pri la afiŝo (spektoj, ŝatoj, komentoj ktp), ankaŭ aliaj atribuoj, ekzemple ĝenroj, venas de Tubaro mem. Ili neniel estas rilataj al tiuj ĉe la originala platformo. Mi komprenas.
Viaj signaloj pri problemoj rilate ĉi tiun afiŝon estos sendataj nur al la administrantoj de Tubaro. Ĉi tiu funkcio neniel estas rilata al ebla simila eco ĉe la originala platformo de la filmo. Por raporti problemon al la administrantoj de la originala platformo, uzu la raportofunkcion ĉe tiu platformo. Mi komprenas.
Priskribo
Esperanto did not lose an argument about grammar. It lost a vote in Geneva. By nineteen twenty two the League of Nations had its own printed report on the desk: Esperanto taught in the schools of three hundred and twenty towns across seventeen countries, evening classes in twelve hundred towns across thirty nine countries, roughly four million textbooks sold. Ten delegates voted in favour. One voted against. That one vote is the whole story, and it never mentions linguistics once.
This video follows the paper trail. The pledge slip at the back of Zamenhof’s first book, which asked you to promise to learn the language only once ten million other people had promised too, and collected about one thousand signatures instead. Neutral Moresnet, three and a half square kilometres of zinc mine that nearly became an Esperanto-speaking state called Amikejo. The French delegate who objected that French was losing its standing as the language of diplomacy, the French ministry circular that shut school premises to Esperanto courses, and the committee under Henri Bergson that quietly resolved to favour a living language instead. Then the part nobody packages as a language story at all: the chapter in Mein Kampf, three German decrees in eighteen months, Himmler’s signature dissolving the organisations, the NKVD charge sheet calling the Soviet Esperantists a spy organisation, Ernest Drezen shot in October nineteen thirty seven, and all three of Zamenhof’s children murdered. At the end, one Hungarian census form settles which invented language actually survived.
Sources are the documents themselves wherever possible. Zamenhof’s Unua Libro in the eighteen eighty nine English translation, the League of Nations Secretariat report Esperanto as an International Auxiliary Language from nineteen twenty two, the Bérard circular of June nineteen twenty two and the Jean Zay circular of October nineteen thirty eight, the Rust, Bormann and Himmler decrees as documented by Ulrich Lins in Dangerous Language, Abram de Swaan on why a language with no speakers is worth nothing to its first learner, and the Hungarian Central Statistical Office census returns for two thousand one, two thousand eleven and two thousand twenty two.
Two things you will hear elsewhere are not in here, because they do not hold up. Stalin never called Esperanto the language of spies in any traceable document. And it was Himmler who signed, not Heydrich, and what he dissolved was the clubs, not the language.
How this video is made: researched from named sources, script written with AI help, AI narration, and every figure checked against a source before upload. Spot a mistake? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.
Chapters:
0:00 Four million textbooks, one objection
0:29 Ten million names, one thousand signatures
1:11 One vote inside the League
2:06 Himmler signs and the network dies
3:35 Four thousand Hungarians and two Interlinguists
Archival images:
– Zinkwerke Neutral-Moresnet (2).jpg – Adolphe Maugendre (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Zinkwerke_Neutral-Moresnet_(2).jpg
– Vulkan Amikejo EFWachau 2017 01.jpg – Anton-kurt (CC BY-SA 3.0) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Vulkan_Amikejo_EFWachau_2017_01.jpg
– Unua Libro fr 001.png – Ludwik Lejzer Zamenhof (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Unua_Libro_fr_001.png
– Grave of Lazaro Ludoviko Zamenhof – 04.jpg – Jolanta Dyr (CC BY-SA 3.0) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Grave_of_Lazaro_Ludoviko_Zamenhof_-_04.jpg
– Librarians of the League of Nations.tif – Unknown author Unknown author (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Librarians_of_the_League_of_Nations.tif
– Henri Bergson 02.jpg – Henri Manuel (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Henri_Bergson_02.jpg
– Gabriel Hanotaux b Meurisse 1921.jpg – Agence de presse Meurisse (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Gabriel_Hanotaux_b_Meurisse_1921.jpg
– Palmiry Cemetery.JPG – User:Mathiasrex Maciej Szczepańczyk (CC BY-SA 3.0) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Palmiry_Cemetery.JPG
– Lidia Zamenhof 1936.jpg – Unknown author Unknown author (Public domain) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lidia_Zamenhof_1936.jpg
Music: “Bright And Mystery” by Lumamorph (CC0) https://freesound.org/people/Lumamorph/sounds/669503
Full footage and image credits are in the pinned comment.
